These are the specific things that should either end a negotiation or dramatically reduce your offer. Not all are deal-breakers in isolation, but each adds risk and cost to ownership.
Start the car cold (engine not run for several hours). A rattle that disappears after 30–60 seconds of running is the timing chain tensioner. This is the most significant mechanical issue on the S2000.
Why it matters: A failed tensioner allows chain slap that can destroy the engine. Tensioner replacement is ~$500–800 in labor and parts, but if ignored, you're looking at a $3,000–5,000 engine rebuild or replacement.
Walk away or demand significant price reduction.
With the engine warm at idle, remove the oil cap. Some light vapor is normal; a strong puff of pressurized air indicates worn piston rings. This is a significant engine wear indicator.
White or milky oil indicates coolant mixing with oil — typically from a blown head gasket or cracked head. Check the dipstick and inside the oil cap. Walk away from any car showing this symptom.
Blue smoke from the exhaust under acceleration means the engine is burning oil through worn valve seals or piston rings. Requires engine work.
Never buy a car with a check engine light on without knowing exactly what codes are stored and why. Pull codes before the test drive.
Inspect the frame rails from underneath. Surface rust is cosmetic; penetrating rust that compresses the metal means structural compromise. An S2000 with compromised frame rails is not safe and not worth buying.
The battery tray under the hood rusts badly on neglected cars. If the tray has rusted through, water has been sitting there for years — check what else is rusted underneath.
Mismatched paint or uneven body gaps indicate a repainted panel — which means prior damage. Not automatically a deal-breaker if it's a minor repair, but probe for full accident history.
A clunk from the rear on tight, slow turns (parking lot maneuvers) that can't be attributed to worn CV axles or wheel bearings indicates differential issues. LSD rebuild or replacement is ~$500–800+.
During the test drive, get into 3rd or 4th gear at moderate speed, then give full throttle while holding steady speed. If the revs spike without corresponding acceleration, the clutch is slipping. Clutch replacement is typically $800–1,200.
A newly replaced convertible top on a car with low mileage is suspicious — ask why. Tops are expensive; people don't replace them unless needed. This could indicate the car was stored improperly, sat exposed for years, or had water damage.
A car that was freshly cleaned and detailed just before sale can hide rust, oil leaks, and wear. Bring a flashlight and look in every corner. Missing maintenance records on a 15+ year old car is a yellow flag.
Check that the mileage on the odometer matches the car's wear and service stickers. Extremely pristine interior on a "100,000 mile" car, or worn pedals and seats on a "30,000 mile" car, warrant investigation.
Always get a pre-purchase inspection from a Honda specialist. Private sellers selling problem cars often pressure buyers to make a quick decision. Any legitimate seller will welcome an independent inspection. If they resist, that's your answer.
Don't see what you're looking for? Suggest a topic →